Letters

Letters 08-03-2015

Real Brownfields Deserve Dollars I read with interest the story on Brownfield development dollars in the July 20 issue. I applaud Dan Lathrop and other county commissioners who voted “No” on the Randolph Street project...

Hopping Mad Carlin Smith is hopping mad (“Will You Get Mad With Me?” 7-20-15). Somebody filed a fraudulent return using his identity, and he’s not alone. The AP estimates the government “pays more than $5 billion annually in fraudulent tax refunds.” Well, many of us have been hopping mad for years. This is because the number one tool Congress has used to fix this problem has been to cut the IRS budget –by $1.2 billion in the last 5 years...

Just Grumbling, No Solutions Mark Pontoni’s grumblings [recent Northern Express column] tell us much about him and virtually nothing about those he chooses to denigrate. We do learn that Pontoni may be the perfect political candidate. He’s arrogant, opinionated and obviously dimwitted...

A Racist Symbol I have to respond to Gordon Lee Dean’s letter claiming that the confederate battle flag is just a symbol of southern heritage and should not be banned from state displays. The heritage it represents was the treasonous effort to continue slavery by seceding from a democratic nation unwilling to maintain such a consummate evil...

Not So Thanks I would like to thank the individual who ran into and knocked over my Triumph motorcycle while it was parked at Lowe’s in TC on Friday the 24th. The $3,000 worth of damage was greatly appreciated. The big dent in the gas tank under the completely destroyed chrome badge was an especially nice touch...

Home · Articles · News · Random Thoughts · Random Thoughts
. . . .

Random Thoughts

George Foster - May 13th, 2004
The stain on America

There is no way to sugarcoat it.
The film footage of U.S. military personnel mistreating Iraqi prisoners is indefensible, the worst and most ill-timed black eye against our country in history. Without weapons of mass destruction and connections to al Qaeda to justify our venture into Iraq, the “high, moral ground” was all we had left.
Did anyone else find it ironic that initial stories surrounding American Thomas Hamill’s escape from his terrorist abductors in Iraq are reporting that Hamill was treated well in captivity? I shudder to think of the consequences for future Americans abducted on the heels of film footage showing us humiliating and abusing Iraqis. Bottom line, Americans abroad are now more vulnerable to mistreatment, themselves.
Several investigations must take their course before we can come to any final conclusions. Regardless, the fallout from these abhorrent acts will affect our image and safety in the world for the rest of our lives. Heads had better roll from legitimate U.S. investigations into this scandal or the world will be justified in believing Americans don’t practice what they preach.
Some apologists have maintained, “Saddam Hussein murdered thousands of Iraqis in those same prisons, so where was the indignation when he abused Iraqis?” That may be true, but since when are our standards of behavior measured against criminal dictators? We should be outraged if only one incident of mistreatment had occurred.
It goes without saying, as our leaders continue to recite, the abuse and torture of prisoners is not what America is all about. We also know something else: don’t be blaming everything on ordinary soldiers. 99% of our military personnel are doing a great job under incredibly stressful circumstances. Such alleged abuse of prisoners can only be a result of a supervised and systematic policy to extract information from prisoners or even worse – to humiliate Iraqis because of cultural or religious differences.
How do we know mistreatment must have come from higher-ups on the chain of command? (1) Unrepentant prison personnel were brazenly laughing while being filmed with prisoners during abusive acts. (2) General Janis Karpinski, formerly in command of Baghdad’s Abu Ghurayb prison, pointed out that intelligence officers controlled the cell blocks where abusive acts against prisoners occurred during interrogation. (3) The sheer number of allegations presented to date from various prisons indicates that reported abuses weren’t isolated incidents. Up to 14 deaths of Iraqi prisoners are under investigation by some media accounts. Additionally, film footage of Iraqis being raped and murdered is rumored to exist.
This investigation will not stop with the court martial of six or seven foot soldiers without the taint of a cover-up. The real question is how high in the ranks does the responsibility for the abuse rise? There will be no G. Gordon Liddy or Oliver North to take the fall for superiors (no one is going to admit authorizing these kinds of barbarous acts unless true). Our democratic system does work - an independent investigation will find the person(s) most responsible the abuse. And, most likely, President Bush will fire Donald Rumsfeld by the time you have a chance to read this article.
Why Rumsfeld, you ask? After all, he didn’t torture anyone. As the Secretary of Defense, he is in charge of the Pentagon and must bear responsibility if unable to control subordinate commanders and the widespread criminal behavior of prison personnel. Ignorance is not an excuse.
If George Bush is the leader I think he is, at the very least he will promote an independent investigation and relieve the secretary of his military duties. The president needs to act boldly and promptly to show the rest of the world that abusive behavior against prisoners is inexcusable and those responsible will be held accountable for their actions.
By the time you read this, Rumsfeld will be history, the prison investigations will be driving at the truth, and we can move on toward regaining our respect as a nation. At least, I hope so.
 
  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 
 

 

 
 
 
Close
Close
Close