The Department of Environmental Quaity comment period on Kennecotts petition to open a metallic sulfide mine on the Yellow Dog Plains is now closed. However, I would like to share my concerns with you about this project.
First, this is no place for a mine. The headwaters of the Salmon Trout River, a pristine tributary of Lake Superior and home to endangered coaster brook trout is one of the worst places in Michigan, if not the world, to put a mine. Any mine. And to even consider a metallic sulfide mine operated by an EPA listed polluting foreign company is more than crazy. Its criminal.
Second, while Michigans new mining law looks good on paper, its a facade. Deficiencies include: No siting criteria or water setbacks making any fragile environment a potential mine site. There is no monitoring along the transportation route. Local zoning control was taken away from governments and the people most affected. The rules are confusing, making the law difficult to enforce.
Third, the Kennecott application is flawed. Essential information on groundwater, surface water, discharge rate, transportation, and safety is missing from the application.
Fourth, this is our state land, not Kennecotts. You dont have to let them use it, so takings isnt an issue. The payoff to the state of Michigan doesnt add up. They get billions. We get few short term jobs, toxic waste dumps, polluted air and water, lower property values, health issues for citizens, and a trashed landscape no one wants to visit, ruining our vital tourism economy. Michigan is being treated like a third world country with state leaders looking on in assent.
In summary, Michigan, Water Wonderland of the U.S., has lost its way and you are leading us down the wrong path. No mine should be sited here, the mining law has no teeth, the application is flawed, and the people of Michigan lose.
We need state leaders to oppose this flawed project. If this mine is permitted on your watch our children and grandchildren will ask: What were you thinking? Think again, because its our land and our water.
Mattea Wellnitz Rapid City
Good Work Nit-Picking
Regarding Rick Coates story on the State Theatre restoration and interview with Michael Moore - minor fact checking: the statement that Willow Run was making Jet fighters for WWII jumped off the page. It was B24 Liberator bombers, not jets. (Check on Wikipedia under Willow Run.)
Trivia: I havent tracked this down yet, but Ive heard several stories that Willow Run not only ultimately produced a bomber an hour, but that they were fully armed, fueled and would roll out of the factory, test fire their guns into an embankment, then fly off to England.
As for the can-do attitude then vs. now, Id have to ask about such things as lawyers, OSHA, and the maze of rules and regulations today. At least this project didnt need an Environmental Impact Statement.
Oh yeah, and doesnt deer season start on November 15th?
But enough nit picking.
Congratulations to Mike and all his helpers, financial and physical. With a special big thanks to the idea of theater etiquette!
For me, growing up in East Lansing, it was the State and Lucon theaters in East Lansing, and the Gladmer and the Grand Michigan Theater in Lansing.
And I heartily applaud redevelopment and re-use of existing facilities. Keep up the good work folks.
JT Hoagland TC
Help Yourself to Health
Regarding healthcare, we need to do our part.
We need to begin to have discussions unabashed, caring discussions.
On any given day, two thirds of high cost healthcare is related to the problems of long term abuse of the body NOT because of unfortunate accidents or bad luck. The abuses I am referencing are to tobacco, food, alcohol, drugs, etc.
You may think I am talking about the extreme person. I am talking about our average, everyday citizen. Once the illnesses begin, they are repetitive, involve numerous hospital stays, and produce lingering, sub par lives. The medical technology and pharmaceutical industries have nicely developed ways to keep us alive.
Enough is enough. We need to have discussions with our physicians, someone, as to WHY we abuse ourselves get down to the root of the problem early on. I appeal to the research community.
We blame the hospitals, physicians, for charging too much; however, we need to realize that WE are the primary problem. Eighty percent of the high cost healthcare is because of US. We expect everyone and everything to save us, take care of us when we get sick from our abuses. We need to change and do our part.
Think about this, be nice to our fellow man struggling with this, and do something.
Jill A. Bronkema TC