I hate that X$*#%@ umpire who is obviously blind as a *%$&X# bat. Glad to
get that off my chest.
Yes, Armando Galarraga pitched the greatest game in Tigers history last
week and was robbed of a wild celebration that was richly deserved the
aftermath of a rare perfect game.
Yes, umpire Jim Joyce shockingly called the Cleveland Indians 27th batter
safe at first. He seemed to be the only person viewing the game who
thought the runners foot beat Galarraga to the bag. Even Joyce admitted
after the game that he mistakenly called the runner safe, ruining
And finally, yes, Baseball Commissioner Bud Selig has the authority to
reverse the call and give Galarraga credit for the out, resulting in one
of only 21 perfect games ever pitched in the Major Leagues.
But at what cost? Despite my own initial anger with the ump, with a little
more thought, it becomes obvious that the games results SHOULD NOT BE
If this call is reversed based on video replay, what other calls should be
changed in baseball history? You may be old enough to remember Lou Brocks
controversial no-slide out at home plate that helped turn the World
Series of 1968 in favor of the Tigers. What if video replay showed Brock
was safe? I dont think todays outraged Tigers fans would be willing to
change that important call, too.
You say you favor the use of instant replay in baseball but to what
extent? We have the technological capability of eliminating umpires on the
field altogether, relying on cameras to make each call. Center field
cameras would be relied upon to determine balls and strikes. Other video
cameras could do a good job of making calls at the bases, determining if
catches are made, if home runs clear the fences, and whether batted balls
are fair or foul. Robots would throw new baseballs to the pitcher.
You can see the absurdity of relying on technology in the extreme, but
where do you draw the line once it becomes a bigger part of the game?
As much as I hated how Galarragas game ended, it would be more disturbing
if Commissioner Selig reverses the umpires call. The human touch added by
umpires is an important part of the game and should not be significantly