When an anti-discrimination ordinance for gay and lesbian citizens was
considered by the Traverse City Commission last month, some locals
wondered why such a measure would even be necessary in this day and
age in America.
Hopefully, you read the enlightening article on that issue by Anne
Stanton in our September 20 issue. Anne reported that discrimination
is still a fact of life for local gay persons, and some have lost
their jobs after being outed.
To its credit, the Traverse
City Commission voted unan-imously to approve an ordinance which bans
discrimination against gay, lesbian and transgender citizens, similar
to that adopted by Kalamazoo and about 20 other Michigan communities.
But if you still have any doubts about the need to extend full civil
rights for gay and lesbian persons, consider the news from last week
For Zach Harrington, the hatred of an anti-gay world finally got to
be too much to bear. Harrington, 19, took his own life after attending
a city council meeting in Oklahoma and sitting through three hours of
anti-gay rants and bigotry.
He was at the meeting to request that his town recognize Gay, Lesbian,
Bisexual and Transgender History Month. Although the council voted in
favor of the proclamation, Zachs parents said their son got such a
toxic overload of hatred from the crowd over issues such as gay
marriage and infiltrating the school system that he couldnt take it
anymore and killed himself.
This was on the heels of the death of Tyler Clementi, 18, a Rutgers
University freshman who committed suicide by jumping off a bridge
after his roommate videotaped him having sex with a male student and
broadcast the act online.
Michigan Assistant Attorney General Andrew Shirvell was discovered
to have a 24/7 online stalking obsession with the gay president of
U-Ms student council, blogging that 18-year-old student Chris
Armstrong is a pervert, Satan‘s representative and promoting a
radical homosexual agenda. Not to mention superimposing a Nazi
swastika on the students face.
At a riot in Belgrade, 100 police and marchers were injured by
hundreds of rock and bomb-throwing hooligans at a gay pride parade.
The protesters chanted Death to homosexuals! and many Serbian gays
stayed home for fear of being targeted.
New York City was shaken by the news that a gang of nine thugs in
the Bronx had kidnapped and tortured a gay man and two gay
Tea Party Republican and New York candidate for governor Carl
Paladino went off on a gay-bashing rant, claiming there is nothing to
be proud of in being a dysfunctional homosexual. Paladinos gay
nephew Jeff Hannon, 23, said he was deeply offended by his uncles
homophobia and quit his campaign.
And the biggest story of the week: a federal judge ordered the
immediate suspension of the Dont Ask, Dont Tell ban on being
openly gay or lesbian in the Armed Forces.
The struggle over the last item makes you question the sincerity of
the freedoms we claim to champion in America under the Constitution,
versus the reality of institutionalized, anti-gay hatred.
As U.S. District Judge Virginia Phillips noted, Dont Ask, Dont
Tell is unconstitutional because the policy, violates due process
rights, freedom of speech and the right to petition the government for
redress of grievances guaranteed by the First Amendment.
In other words, its a gag rule violating the most fundamental
American right to speak your mind and declare who and what you stand
It seems amazing that an estimated 66,000 gay and lesbian members of
the Armed Forces have had to hide their sexual orientation while
defending the U.S. Constitution and the principle of free speech. Yet
13,500 servicemen have been discharged under Dont Ask, Dont Tell
since the law was enacted in 1993.
Despite the fact that a lawsuit against this policy was brought to the
federal courts by the Log Cabin Republicans -- a gay rights group made
up of 19,000 members -- in September, all 40 Republican members of the
U.S. Senate voted against a Defense Department bill that would have
repealed Dont Ask, Dont Tell.
All of the above is evidence that gay and lesbian persons still live
in a world of institutionalized violence and injustice.
Consider that one-third of all teenagers who commit suicide are gay.
And kids who fear being rejected by their parents for coming out are
said to be eight times more likely to attempt suicide.
This is a passive form of culturally-encouraged genocide: gay teens
are haunted by the stigma and censure of their classmates and bullied
to a breaking point.
Young gay individuals realize that they must hide their identity for
fear of social and legal consequences which can destroy their lives,
states an article on Stopping Gay Teen Suicide by Ciara Torres at
www.healthyplace.com. Homosexuals can be fired, evicted, kept from
their own biological children, restricted from adopting children, and
imprisoned for sodomy. The homosexuality of historical figures has
been systematically left out of education in the public schools,
giving gay youth the false impression that gays have never affected
history in a positive way.
Today, although the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s is some 50
years in the past, gay and lesbian Americans have no legal protection
from employment or housing discrimination in 42 states. And there are
still laws on the books dating back to Colonial times which
criminalize same-sex acts in 45 states.
As for marriage, it seems odd that even heterosexuals who have poorer
parenting skills than barnyard animals can get married or divorced on
a drunken whim, all with the blessing of religious fundamentalists who
go ballistic when homosexual citizens seek to sanctify their own
When the Jews of East Europe faced extermination and ethnic cleansing
in the early 20th century, many did a sensible thing and emigrated to
America, Palestine and other safe havens. The Jews were able to create
their own fortress/sanctuary in the state of Israel.
Yet gay and lesbian persons have no Israel to retreat to from a
hostile world. They are at best hidden in plain sight, and often
poorly so at that. Yet they too have been subjected to injustice, hate
crimes, and the kind of bullying that encourages suicide in young
people at a fragile age.
We can be proud of Traverse City for supporting the principle of
liberty and justice for all, and should encourage every com-munity
in Northern Michigan to follow suit.