Out in the Cold

As winter approaches, homelessness experts emphasize the importance of permanent supportive housing

Across northwest Michigan, hundreds of individuals and families go to sleep every night in their car, a city park, the woods, or a homeless shelter. Every morning, they wake up not sure where they will sleep the next night.

Emma Moyer, the new director at Northwest Michigan Coalition to End Homelessness, says that while progress is being made thanks to the Housing and Homelessness Task Force (a collaborative, community-wide initiative designed to create a long-term response to homelessness), several factors are making it difficult to fully end homelessness Up North.

A System Under Pressure

According to Moyer, about the same number of people are experiencing homelessness as one year ago, but they are staying in the system longer.

“The number of people in the system isn’t going up, which is a good thing, but individuals and families are staying in the system longer, meaning it’s becoming more challenging to find permanent housing,” says Moyer.

Housing costs are at an all-time high across northwest Michigan, with Grand Traverse County reporting less than 1 percent vacancy rates for rentals and Leelanau County reaching first place in the state for the most expensive median home sale price.

Moyer says factors like the lack of available homes and the high cost of the few available homes ultimately force people into a system designed for acute, short-term care, not long-term support. Shelters and rapid response care for the homeless are life-saving remedies, but they are not permanent solutions, Moyer says.

“And when you couple housing inaccessibility with wage stagnation and soaring costs for food, gasoline, utilities, healthcare, clothing, and other essentials, it’s no wonder people experiencing homelessness, a majority of whom are employed, are having a more difficult time finding a permanent housing solution,” Moyer adds.

A Focus on Permanent Housing

Moyer says the fix is not as simple as getting a roof over someone’s head.

“Street outreach and shelters bring people off the street and into a safe place temporarily, but permanent housing is the critical intervention that this population needs,” Moyer says.

Moyer describes permanent supportive housing as being the place that individuals in the homelessness system ultimately arrive at. It’s one of the last steps in the Eight Recommendations, a strategic, evidence-based model she and the Coalition partners have been implementing alongside city and county governments.

“Permanent supportive housing is a combination of housing and services designed for people with serious mental illnesses or other disabilities who need support to live stably in their communities,” Moyer explains.

She says this approach is the linchpin to getting people housed and keeping them housed, because the model includes other essential services like case management, substance abuse or mental health counseling, advocacy, and help locating and maintaining employment.

“Permanent supportive housing is a proven, evidence-based solution for people who have experienced chronic homelessness,” Moyer adds. “The model helps people stay in homes by simply addressing their unique needs that, if left unaddressed, might lead to them losing that housing.”

Moyer says between 80-90 percent of people who have experienced chronic homelessness become permanently housed when they experience truly supportive housing. “But that ‘supportive’ aspect is key,” Moyer notes.

We asked Moyer for examples of what supportive housing looks like.

“Helping individuals get to their appointments for medical or behavioral health treatment, guidance on how to pay utility bills, how to be a good neighbor, the responsibilities of a leaseholder, even coaching on tasks as simple but essential as taking the trash to the curb and keeping the yard maintained are all critical pieces of supportive housing,” she says.

Anticipating Budget Cuts

Current permanent supportive housing providers in the Traverse City area include Goodwill Northern Michigan’s East Bay Flats (64 apartments), Annika Place II (19 housing units), Carson Square, and Northwest Michigan Supportive Housing’s scattered-site housing model, which contracts with about 40 private landlords to supply 72 units for permanent supportive housing purposes.

Moyer says these resources are a good start, but funding shortfalls and the threat of budget cuts create a severe bottleneck in creating the scale of supportive housing needed to end homelessness.

“Once permanent supportive housing units are set up, it’s actually much cheaper to transition people who are experiencing homelessness into permanent supportive housing than it is to stand up and run multiple 24/7 homelessness shelter sites,” Moyer says. “But the upfront capital investment and building costs are so high, it serves as a barrier to communities developing the housing units needed to get people out of the homelessness system and into permanent housing.”

The funding issue could get much worse in the months ahead. The federal government’s Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) provides billions of dollars annually in competitive funding to Continuums of Care (CoCs). These programs provide community-wide solutions to reduce homelessness.

Not only did the Trump Administration express its intent in April of this year to slash HUD funding in Fiscal Year 2027 (FY2027) by 13 percent, but the administration proposed eliminating CoCs altogether. Congress pushed back by proposing a FY2027 HUD funding bill that would keep CoCs, but only after cutting their funding by more than 30 percent.

“On the provider side, how do you plan for providing services when the government is talking about 30 percent cuts?” Moyer asks.

“And for those we serve, how do they fight the daily battle of finding a place to sleep tonight, when they don’t even know if the services they’ve relied on for survival will be funded and available to help them tomorrow?”

What the Community Can Do to Help

Moyer listed four key asks she and others within the Coalition make to community members:

1. Volunteer. “Much of the nonprofits, shelters, housing programs, and kitchens do really important work on very limited budgets, and they rely on volunteers to make that work happen,” Moyer says, listing Safe Harbor, Goodwill, and Jubilee House as being three organizations always in need of volunteers.

2. Donate money. “Always, but especially now and in the months to come, the work to end homelessness is significantly underfunded,” Moyer says. “Agencies across the Coalition require financial contributions from caring individuals to provide services and housing in our communities.”

3. Advocate. “Inform the public, pressure elected officials, and raise awareness that the existence of homelessness within our communities does not have to be a foregone conclusion,” Moyer recommends. “With enough public pressure and enough awareness and political will brought to bear, we can solve this problem.”

4. Donate things. “We mentioned earlier that the cost of essentials has skyrocketed, making at-risk families have to choose between food, shelter, clothing, gasoline, etc.,” Moyer adds. “We rely on the community to show up for our homeless neighbors and make it so they don’t have to choose which basic essentials they must find a way to live without.”

Learn more about the Coalition’s work and how to get involved at endhomelessnessnmi.org.

View On Our Website