December 15, 2025

Koeze Cream-Nut Peanut Butter

Tastemaker
By Kristi Kates | June 9, 2018

Skippy Peanut Butter has been around since 1932. Jif has been on shelves since 1958. And Planters brought their Mr. Peanut-approved peanut butter to consumers in 2015.

But Koeze Company’s Cream-Nut Peanut Butter is among the oldest brands in the bunch — the company has been making peanut butter since 1925, right here in Michigan.

Using the same recipe they started with in the early ’20s, the company still makes their all-natural peanut butter on a lineup of vintage equipment, slow-roasting the peanuts first before slow-grinding them into peanut butter, only using Virginia-variety peanuts and sea salt, with no additional additives.

Cream-Nut’s sister peanut butter brand, Sweet Ella’s, uses organic Spanish peanuts. Both are a treat for peanut butter fans — perfect for cookie baking, in a smoothie, and, of course, as the better half of that longtime classic, the humble peanut butter and jelly sandwich.

Order online and get Koeze’s shipped to you directly from Grand Rapids, starting at $6.49 per jar or $67.88 for a case of 12. koeze.com.

Trending

Welcoming the Winter Solstice: Rituals & Events for the Shortest Day of the Year

With the winter solstice quickly approaching, it’s hard not to notice how dark each day feels. Astronomically, this is… Read More >>

Camp Greilick Now Open!

It’s been a long road for the century-old Camp Greilick, which, after several dormant years, was acquired by Grand Tra… Read More >>

Men and Ugly Sweaters

Those two things don’t always go together, but on Dec. 19, you’ll see both out and about in Petoskey and Harbor … Read More >>

MRKT HLDY SHPPNG, aka Warehouse MRKT Holiday Shopping!

Shop the latest from local makers and vendors at the Holiday MRKT Share at Warehouse MRKT in TC, Saturday, Dec. 20, from 10a… Read More >>