November 18, 2026

Slabtown Cookie Co.’s Summer Magic & Kegger

Tastemaker
By Lynda Wheatley | Sept. 12, 2020

While the rest of us spent the early days of the pandemic climbing the walls, watching Netflix, and baking cookies, Katie Otterman was doing the same. Only she — a single mom of a 6-year-old son and 8-year-old daughter — turned that latter boredom buster into a booming business, one that started as a Michigan Cottage Food Law-approved cooler of cookies for sale in her Traverse City front yard … and is now also a commercial enterprise serving nearly a half-dozen local retailers (plus the original multitude of cooler-sniffing locals).

She told Northern Express that she credits the local folks’ support for her astonishing two-month trajectory, but we’re here to tell you, she’s wrong; their word-of-mouth marketing is due entirely to her out-of-this-world crispy-chewy-tender-and-totally-inspired cookie creations.

We stopped by to sample some last week, and let’s just say that “Oh my Gawd!” accompanied by giant saucer eyes and racoon-like pawing was the universal reaction to both treats we tried: the Summer Magic (a truly magically delicious cookie made with Lucky Charms cereal and white chocolate chips, $4 each) and a Kegger (an incredibly moist dark chocolate beer brownie topped with more chocolate and crushed peanut butter cups, $5).

Otterman begins baking every day at 5am and each morning reveals the day’s menu on Slabtown Cookie Co.’s Instagram feed. Keep up and order there, or stroll to her no-contact self-service stand at 228 Monroe St. (open 10am–8pm daily) and behold thy cooler bounty. Cash and Venmo accepted.

Trending

Still, Life with Corrina Ulrich

Few things can halt the pace of life like the sight of Lake Michigan crashing against the shore or taking in a piece of art.… Read More >>

Inside Blue Heron Gallery

Several pieces of Dan Reszka’s art adorn the walls of Blue Heron Gallery in Elk Rapids. He enjoys making it. He likes … Read More >>

Threading the Needle

During the darkness of the COVID-19 pandemic, an intriguing trend emerged. “Grandma hobbies”—old-fashioned… Read More >>

Where Music Meets Nature

From art galleries to center stage, artist Dana Falconberry dances to the beat of her own drum. Locals in Austin, Texas, rec… Read More >>
↑