January 24, 2022

Prisons and Jails: The New Asylums

Guest Column
By Mary Keyes Rogers | Jan. 20, 2018

When did Americans decide that incarceration was acceptable housing for the seriously mentally ill?

According to one advocacy agency for inmates: In 44 states, a jail or prison holds more mentally ill individuals than the largest remaining state psychiatric hospital; in every county in the United States with both a county jail and a county psychiatric facility, more seriously mentally ill individuals are incarcerated than hospitalized.

Family and friends of the newly incarcerated mentally ill can be heard saying: “It was just a matter of time. We tried to get them help. Our hands were tied until they broke the law.”

There is a direct correlation between the rising rate of incarcerations and the closing of state hospitals for psychiatric patients. Law enforcement has been put on the front line as first-responders to mental illness, funneling our most vulnerable and yet sometimes dangerously mentally ill population into ill-suited hospital emergency rooms, jails, and prisons where appropriate treatment is not funded or available.

Over time, reduced government funding for the diagnosis and treatment of mental illness has been effectively shifted away from public health to law enforcement and incarceration budgets. Also picking up the bill: private sector non-profits.

It is my opinion that our society as a whole is paying the price for the reduction of public spending for the diagnosis and treatment (including institutionalized treatment, if needed) of serious mental illness. These people deserve better; the current situation is inhumane.

True enough, there was a time in this country when state mental hospitals were filled with patients who had been involuntarily committed to institutional care, many sedated into submission for easier management (rather than treated), and rarely if ever, released. But there were also public institutions offering the latest treatment methods with great success. 

Consider that approximately one-third of all homeless are mentally ill. Many will commit petty theft just to survive.

The National Council reports while at least half of prisoners have some mental health concerns, about 10 to 25 percent of U.S. prisoners suffer from serious mental illnesses, such as major affective disorders or schizophrenia. Some estimates put the number of seriously mentally ill inmates in jails or prisons at 50 percent.

The height of institutionalized psychiatric care came in 1958 with over 550,000 state hospital beds for the most serious cases of schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, severe chronic depression, etc. Mental patients were largely kept out of the public eye and out of the public square.

Sixty years later, with the closing of state hospitals, mental patients still remain largely out of sight, incarcerated or living on the streets, untreated, and likely headed for an encounter with the judicial system. Instead of restrictive psychiatric institutions with hospital beds, more people with serious mental disorders will find themselves in solitary confinement or SHUs (Special Housing Units) in a prison.

Over the course of time, a few important changes have taken place:

●      New medications became available, making it seem possible for many patients to live independently and lead productive lives

●      The rising legal standing of an individual’s right to refuse treatment

●      States moving to ever-decreasing public funding for community-based mental health programs

●      A 95 percent decrease in the number of public hospital beds for seriously mentally ill patients

●      Mental health diagnosis and treatment is, by and large, now paid for at the discretion of private health insurance companies, with consumers responsible for large deductibles and copays. 

Before moving to Traverse City, I worked in the hustle bustle of downtown Detroit’s historic office buildings. In the 1990s, Michigan’s public mental health system was effectively dismantled. One of Detroit’s greatest community assets was The Lafayette Clinic, a state-funded inpatient psychiatric hospital that was lauded for its leading-edge advancements in the treatment of psychiatric conditions. 

Under Governor John Engler, funding was eliminated, and the doors were thrown wide open. It was asserted that a network of public community mental health programs would fill the need for treatment of the patients. That did not happen, and the patients of The Lafayette Clinic became residents of our streets — essentially, our insane and unmedicated neighbors.

In those first cold winter months, my coworkers and I would give money, food, blankets, and coats to our new neighbors who were living in stairwells and behind dumpsters, only to walk past them the next day and find them without.

One by one, these people either committed crimes that landed them in jail or prison, or they died living on the streets. That is what community-based mental health looked like to me.

Twenty-five years later, there still seems an inhumane and inadequate social safety net for the mentally ill. Last year, Michigan House Speaker Tom Leonard created the bipartisan House C.A.R.E.S. (Community, Access, Resources, Education, and Safety) task force to receive input from individuals and professionals on how to improve mental health services in Michigan. No action yet. 

Mary Rogers is a Traverse City resident, blogger, and podcaster. mary@experience50.com



Homelessness Up North

Across the northwest Lower Peninsula, hundreds of Michiganders are struggling to find shelter this winter. It’s not... Read More >>

Little Traverse Conservancy's Best Year Ever

Maybe 2021 stunk for most of the world, but in one little corner of it, last year was its best ever: “In 2021, more ... Read More >>

New Districts, Same Players

We're now well into our constitutionally required decennial exercise in reapportioning legislative and congressional distr... Read More >>

What Will it Take?

  If you’ve seen the recently released Netflix comedy “Don’t Look Up,” you might be asking t... Read More >>